Discussion: View Thread

  • 1.  Thompson's High Impact Articles list

    Posted 03-08-2006 16:28
    Thompson has a database that ranks the highest cited articles in management (and other fields) using the social science citation index, and controlling for the "expected" number of cites an article would have received based on its data of publication, journal, etc. I'm not sure how far back their time frame goes -- I do not think it goes back far enough to pick up some of the "classics", but as of a couple of years ago the top ten "high impact" articles they had identified for management (and their cites) were the following (note, only first author is listed):
     
    Barney (1991, Journal of Management) 904 cites
    Ajzen (1991, OBDHP) 845 cites
    Cohen (1990, ASQ) 691 cites
    Eisenhardt (1989, AMR) 620 cites
    Wernerfelt (1984, SMJ) 611 cites
    Daft (1986, Mgmt Sci) 497 cites
    Banker (1984, Mgmt Sci) 493 cites
    Tushman (1986, ASQ) 492 cites
    Hambrick (1984, AMR) 483 cites
    Daft (1984, AMR) 463 cites
     
    -Melissa Schilling
    904 66.81 13.53091 658 Barney J 99 17 Firm resources Mgmt J Manag 1991
    845 36.19 23.34899 Ajzen I 179 50 the theory of Mgmt Organ Behav 1991
    691 131.33 5.261555 658 Cohen WM 128 35 Absorptive Capacity Mgmt Adm Sci Qua 1990
    620 96.5 6.42487 658 Eisenhardt 532 14 Building Mgmt Acad Mgmt R 1989
    611 62.35 9.799519 658 Wernerfelt B 171 5 A Mgmt Strat Manag 1984
    497 34.61 14.36001 658 Daft RL 554 32 Organizational Mgmt Manag Sci 1986
    493 30 16.43333 658 Banker Rd 1078 30 Some models Mgmt Manag Sci 1984
    492 73.5 6.693878 658 Tushman ML 439 31 Technological Mgmt Adm Sci Qua 1986
    483 50.8 9.507874 658 Hambrick DC 193 9 Upper echelons Mgmt Acad Mgmt R 1984
    463 50.8 9.114173 658 Daft RL 284 9 Toward a Mgmt Acad Mgmt R 1984
     
    Barney J 99 17 Firm resources Mgmt J Manag
    Ajzen I 179 50 the theory of Mgmt Organ Behav
    Cohen WM 128 35 Absorptive Capacity Mgmt Adm Sci Qua
    Eisenhardt 532 14 Building Mgmt Acad Mgmt R
    Wernerfelt B 171 5 A Mgmt Strat Manag
    Daft RL 554 32 Organizational Mgmt Manag Sci
    Banker Rd 1078 30 Some models Mgmt Manag Sci
    Tushman ML 439 31 Technological Mgmt Adm Sci Qua
    Hambrick DC 193 9 Upper echelons Mgmt Acad Mgmt R
    Daft RL 284 9 Toward a Mgmt Acad Mgmt R
    -----Original Message-----
    From: Business Policy and Strategy List [mailto:BPS-NET@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU]On Behalf Of Dr. Carlos Alcerreca
    Sent: Wednesday, March 08, 2006 1:40 PM
    To: BPS-NET@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    Subject: most cited

    I need to design a PhD course on the "Foundations of Management". One possible approach to design such a course would be to use the most cited articles in Management. I have seen articles listing the most cited articles in Finance, but I have not seen a recent list of the 30-50 most cited articles in the top Management journals. Do you know where I could find such a list?
    Carlos Alcérreca
    ITAM-Mexico
     


  • 2.  Thompson's High Impact Articles list

    Posted 03-10-2006 11:28
    Thanks Melissa.
    Carlos
    ----- Original Message -----
    Sent: Wednesday, March 08, 2006 3:28 PM
    Subject: Thompson's High Impact Articles list

    Thompson has a database that ranks the highest cited articles in management (and other fields) using the social science citation index, and controlling for the "expected" number of cites an article would have received based on its data of publication, journal, etc. I'm not sure how far back their time frame goes -- I do not think it goes back far enough to pick up some of the "classics", but as of a couple of years ago the top ten "high impact" articles they had identified for management (and their cites) were the following (note, only first author is listed):
     
    Barney (1991, Journal of Management) 904 cites
    Ajzen (1991, OBDHP) 845 cites
    Cohen (1990, ASQ) 691 cites
    Eisenhardt (1989, AMR) 620 cites
    Wernerfelt (1984, SMJ) 611 cites
    Daft (1986, Mgmt Sci) 497 cites
    Banker (1984, Mgmt Sci) 493 cites
    Tushman (1986, ASQ) 492 cites
    Hambrick (1984, AMR) 483 cites
    Daft (1984, AMR) 463 cites
     
    -Melissa Schilling
    904 66.81 13.53091 658 Barney J 99 17 Firm resources Mgmt J Manag 1991
    845 36.19 23.34899 Ajzen I 179 50 the theory of Mgmt Organ Behav 1991
    691 131.33 5.261555 658 Cohen WM 128 35 Absorptive Capacity Mgmt Adm Sci Qua 1990
    620 96.5 6.42487 658 Eisenhardt 532 14 Building Mgmt Acad Mgmt R 1989
    611 62.35 9.799519 658 Wernerfelt B 171 5 A Mgmt Strat Manag 1984
    497 34.61 14.36001 658 Daft RL 554 32 Organizational Mgmt Manag Sci 1986
    493 30 16.43333 658 Banker Rd 1078 30 Some models Mgmt Manag Sci 1984
    492 73.5 6.693878 658 Tushman ML 439 31 Technological Mgmt Adm Sci Qua 1986
    483 50.8 9.507874 658 Hambrick DC 193 9 Upper echelons Mgmt Acad Mgmt R 1984
    463 50.8 9.114173 658 Daft RL 284 9 Toward a Mgmt Acad Mgmt R 1984
     
    Barney J 99 17 Firm resources Mgmt J Manag
    Ajzen I 179 50 the theory of Mgmt Organ Behav
    Cohen WM 128 35 Absorptive Capacity Mgmt Adm Sci Qua
    Eisenhardt 532 14 Building Mgmt Acad Mgmt R
    Wernerfelt B 171 5 A Mgmt Strat Manag
    Daft RL 554 32 Organizational Mgmt Manag Sci
    Banker Rd 1078 30 Some models Mgmt Manag Sci
    Tushman ML 439 31 Technological Mgmt Adm Sci Qua
    Hambrick DC 193 9 Upper echelons Mgmt Acad Mgmt R
    Daft RL 284 9 Toward a Mgmt Acad Mgmt R
    -----Original Message-----
    From: Business Policy and Strategy List [mailto:BPS-NET@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU]On Behalf Of Dr. Carlos Alcerreca
    Sent: Wednesday, March 08, 2006 1:40 PM
    To: BPS-NET@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
    Subject: most cited

    I need to design a PhD course on the "Foundations of Management". One possible approach to design such a course would be to use the most cited articles in Management. I have seen articles listing the most cited articles in Finance, but I have not seen a recent list of the 30-50 most cited articles in the top Management journals. Do you know where I could find such a list?
    Carlos Alcérreca
    ITAM-Mexico